The BBQ Shack Menu (2025 Update)
Welcome to The BBQ Shack, a hidden gem located at 2447 NY-54A, Penn Yan, NY. This cozy spot is dedicated to serving up mouthwatering barbecue delights that will tantalize your taste buds. The menu boasts a variety of standout dishes, including the succulent Triple B Burger, which combines cheeseburger goodness with brisket, bacon, and rich BBQ sauce, all for just $13.00.
For those craving a feast, the Sampler is a must-try, featuring a 1/4 rack of ribs, chicken, and sliders—a perfect way to experience the best of what The BBQ Shack offers at $27.00. Kids won’t be left out, with tasty chicken tenders and cheeseburgers priced at $11.50 each.
With dedicated service and an inviting atmosphere, The BBQ Shack is a haven for BBQ lovers in the area, making every visit an experience to remember.
Just the Meats
BBQ Nachos
1/2 Dozen Sliders
Choose from pulled pork or beef brisket.
BBQ Chicken (Leg Quarter)
Giant leg quarter.
1 Dozen Sliders
Choose from pulled pork or beef brisket.
Whole Rack Ribs
1/2 Lb Beef Brisket
Price is per half pound.
1 Pound Pulled Pork
Comes with sauce on the side.
1/2 Rack Ribs
Pulled Pork Sandwich
1/2 Pound Pulled Pork
Comes with sauce on the side.
Chicken Wing Dip
12 ounce container. Served with tortilla chips.
Macaroni Salad
12 ounce container.
Fresh Cut Fries
BBQ Beans
12 ounce container.
Coleslaw
12 ounce container.
Mac And Cheese
Cornbread
2 Pieces
Salt Potatoes
6 to 8 small potatoes served with butter.
Pasta Salad
12 ounce container.
Sides
From the Chargrill / Fryer
Grilled Chicken Sandwich
Marinated grilled chicken breast with lettuce, tomato, and mayo on a roll.
Fresh Cut Fries
Chicken Tenders (4)
Johnny Fries
Our fresh cut fries smothered with cheese sauce, meat sauce, and onions.
Bacon Double Cheeseburger
Bacon double cheeseburger.
Hoffman's Hot Dog
The Samson Plate (Half Plate) - The West Plate
Mac salad, home fries, your choice of 1 cheeseburger or 1 hot dog, topped with Doc Rochester's meat sauce.
The BBQ Plate
Your choice of two sides and up to 2 meats. Choose between pulled pork or pulled chicken, beef brisket, or boneless rib meat, topped with BBQ sauce.
BBQ Fries
Our fresh cut fries smothered in cheese sauce, pulled pork, and BBQ sauce.
Triple B Burger
Our cheeseburger topped with brisket, bacon, and BBQ sauce.
Cheeseburger
Cheeseburger comes dressed. Add bacon for an additional charge.
The West Lake Plate
Mac salad, homefries, your choice of 2 cheeseburgers or 2 hot dogs, topped with Doc Rochester's meat sauce, onions, ketchup, and mustard.
BBQ Cheeseburger
Cheeseburger topped with pulled pork and BBQ sauce.
SGT. Wilber Sandwich
Beef brisket and pulled pork together topped with BBQ sauce.
Pulled Pork Sandwich
Pulled Chicken Sandwich
1/3 Rack Ribs
BBQ Chicken
Giant leg quarter.
The Puckered Pig
Pulled pork sandwich topped with cheese sauce, BBQ sauce, and bacon.
BBQ Brisket Sandwich
Roger That
Beef brisket, pulled pork, and pulled chicken on a dipaolo roll topped with BBQ sauce.
Lunch Combos
Dinner Combos
Pulled Chicken Sandwich
On a soft roll. Topped with bbq sauce
BBQ Chicken
Giant Chicken Leg Quarter
Pulled Pork Sandwich
On a soft roll. Topped with bbq sauce.
1/2 Rack Ribs
Baby Back Ribs, topped with BBQ.
Sampler
1/4 Rack Ribs, Piece of Chicken, 2 Pork Sliders, 2 Brisket Sliders
Two Meat Combo
Your choice of two meats
1/3 Rack Ribs
Baby Back Ribs, topped with BBQ.